voltronvault.com / Movie / The Voltron rights fight
RightsThe Voltron rights fight
Voltron is an English re-edit of two unrelated Toei series. That is why a live-action film took so long, and why two federal lawsuits were filed over it.
The rights fight nobody writes up
Voltron: Defender of the Universe is an English re-edit of two unrelated Toei series, Beast King GoLion and Armored Fleet Dairugger XV, licensed and recombined in St. Louis. That is a fine arrangement for a cartoon and a difficult one for a film, because it leaves two companies on two continents with defensible views about what was actually sold.
The first fight came in 1998, when World Events produced Voltron: The Third Dimension in CGI without Toei. It settled in 2000 with new agreements and an assignment. What that settlement actually divided is the single most confidently repeated unsourced claim in Voltron’s history: the version you will read says World Events walked away with the animated properties outright, but the reporting closest to the pleadings declines to describe the division at all. We are not going to pretend to know.
What is documented is what happened next. On 9 August 2007, the same day Variety broke the New Regency deal, World Events sold live-action rights without consulting Toei. Toei wrote back to say that in its view the settlement had not given World Events "an exclusive right for live-action movie for Voltron", on the reasoning that animation and live action are completely different products. New Regency then ran its own rights check and turned up a third party: Kazuo Nakamura, the Toei artist who led character design on GoLion, who World Events’ own complaint conceded "may possess rights that encumber the Golion and/or Voltron properties."
World Events sued twice for a declaration of who owned what.
| Court | Docket | Filed | Terminated |
|---|---|---|---|
| E.D. Missouri | 4:08-cv-00163 | 1 February 2008 | 28 September 2010 |
| C.D. California | 2:08-cv-06607 | 7 October 2008 | 29 April 2009 |
New Regency did not wait for the answer. It abandoned the film in August 2008, unable to close with the rights holders, and World Events later pleaded that the dispute had cost it at least one development deal that would have produced an actual movie. The terms of the eventual settlement are not public. A second suit, brought in September 2009 by the producers who said they had held an exclusive Voltron deal since 2004, fouled the Atlas era on the way past. The two-series origin that caused all of this is on the Fleet of Doom page.
The attempts this dispute killed are on the history page. The film that eventually got made is on the overview.